Nicomachean Ethics vs. Barbarian Days by William Finnegan
Nicomachean Ethics
"Nicomachean Ethics," written by the ancient Greek philosopher Aristotle, is a foundational text in Western philosophy. This work explores the nature of ethical virtue and the path to a good and fulfilling life. Aristotle delves into concepts such as happiness (eudaimonia), virtue (arete), and the importance of practical wisdom (phronesis). The text is a detailed examination of how individuals can achieve moral and intellectual virtues through habitual practice and rational deliberation.
Barbarian Days by William Finnegan
Barbarian Days: A Surfing Life is William Finnegan’s story about growing up obsessed with surfing. It’s not just about catching waves—it’s about a whole way of life that’s demanding, addictive, and sometimes dangerous. Finnegan started young, learning to surf in California and Hawaii, and kept chasing waves into adulthood, traveling through places like Fiji, Australia, Indonesia, and Africa. Along the way, he mixes adventure with self-reflection, talking about friendships formed in the water, the culture around surfing, and how it all fit with the times—especially during the social changes of the 1960s and '70s. The book isn’t just about the thrill of surfing; Finnegan dives into the technical side of waves and the patience it takes to master them. He’s honest about his youthful recklessness—like taking LSD before surfing a massive wave in Maui—and the risks that came with his travels, from malaria scares to navigating shady markets. Still, surfing pulls him along, even when he’s jugg...
Reviews
Reviews
Reviewed on 2/25/2025
| Item | Votes | Upvote |
|---|---|---|
| Essential reading for students of philosophy and ethics | 1 | |
| Practical wisdom | 1 | |
| Offers profound reflections on ethics and the good life | 1 |
| Item | Votes | Upvote |
|---|---|---|
| Dense and complex | 1 |
| Item | Votes | Upvote |
|---|---|---|
| No pros yet, would you like to add one? | ||
| Item | Votes | Upvote |
|---|---|---|
| No cons yet, would you like to add one? | ||
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, Nicomachean Ethics is generally considered more valuable for understanding ethics as it is a foundational text in Western philosophy that explores ethical virtue, happiness, and practical wisdom. In contrast, Barbarian Days is an autobiography focused on surfing and personal experiences, which does not delve into ethical theories or philosophical concepts.
Nicomachean Ethics explicitly discusses the concept of practical wisdom (phronesis) as essential for achieving moral and intellectual virtues. Barbarian Days, while it may offer insights into the author's life and experiences, does not focus on practical wisdom or ethical teachings, making Nicomachean Ethics the more relevant choice for those seeking practical wisdom.
Yes, Nicomachean Ethics is often described as dense and complex, requiring careful reading and contemplation to fully grasp its concepts. In contrast, Barbarian Days is an autobiography that is likely to be more accessible and straightforward, focusing on narrative rather than philosophical discourse.
'Nicomachean Ethics,' written by the ancient Greek philosopher Aristotle, is a foundational text in Western philosophy. This work explores the nature of ethical virtue and the path to a good and fulfilling life. Aristotle delves into concepts such as happiness (eudaimonia), virtue (arete), and the importance of practical wisdom (phronesis). The text is a detailed examination of how individuals can achieve moral and intellectual virtues through habitual practice and rational deliberation.
Pros of 'Nicomachean Ethics' include it being essential reading for students of philosophy and ethics, offering practical wisdom, and providing profound reflections on ethics and the good life. However, a con is that the text can be dense and complex.
'Barbarian Days: A Surfing Life' is a memoir by William Finnegan that chronicles his lifelong obsession with surfing. The book explores not only the thrill of catching waves but also the culture surrounding surfing, the friendships formed in the water, and the personal reflections that come with a life dedicated to this demanding and sometimes dangerous sport. Finnegan shares his experiences from California and Hawaii to Fiji, Australia, Indonesia, and Africa, blending adventure with introspection.
'Barbarian Days' delves into several themes, including the passion and addiction associated with surfing, the risks involved in pursuing this lifestyle, and the impact of social changes during the 1960s and '70s. Finnegan reflects on his youthful recklessness, the technical aspects of surfing, and the balance between his career as a war reporter and his love for the ocean.
William Finnegan's writing in 'Barbarian Days' is characterized by vivid descriptions and a reflective tone. He captures both the beauty and the challenges of surfing, making readers feel as if they are experiencing the adventures alongside him. His narrative combines storytelling with insightful observations about life, friendship, and the allure of the ocean.
While there are no specific pros and cons listed for 'Barbarian Days', readers often appreciate its engaging storytelling and deep exploration of surfing culture. Some may find the technical aspects of surfing and the author's personal reflections to be less appealing if they are not interested in the sport. Overall, it is celebrated for its literary quality and the way it captures the essence of a life spent chasing waves.
